Sir-Davey's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Hostage Situation 2]

You have no idea how much this flash inspired me to make my own stuff. It's still very impressively animated and drawn after 23 years.

[Dot Dot Dot - Animated]

Blew my mind

The text animation was great, but if it weren't for the jaw-dropping dramatic reading of the review, this definitely wouldn't be as funny!

I'd love to see more!

[-In Response-]

Decent

That was pretty good but tell your voice actors to use a de-esser filter.

[Refresh's LD Adventure]

Quality flash right here

That was a pretty wild ride. Loved it thoroughly

[LL - Zombi]

Has the potential to be the greatest lock flash

That was truly the best lock flash I've ever seen. You have a realy sense of cinematography, some scenes went really well with the score. And the lighting and pacing were splendid.

It's a real shame you didn't actually finish it, because you seemed to be pretty close from what I could tell. Guess you got lazy, which is understandable. Maybe you can release a "Zombi DVD" like I did where you actually finish that shit!

Come on coffee, I know you can do it.

[Rain Dogs]

Wow!

Good work on this one. It was funny and well made, good job!

[TheLongStory Ep.002]

Most excellent

That was impressive. Loved it!

Madanimation responds:

Thanks for the review!

[Windows big parody 1]

Way overdone

This has seriously been way overdone. Try looking in the collections page, there's an entire category for this sort of stuff and yours definitely doesn't stand out.

And who the hell uses Windows 98 anymore?

kidpaddle59 responds:

Me for the exemple !!

[Simple 3D Board Game Film]

Boring.

Where to start? The lighting was actually pretty good, but that's pretty much the only good thing I can think about.

For starters, try modeling something instead of using primitive boxes and cylinders... second, cut down on the raytraced reflections, that's the only material you seem to have and that's just not very interesting.

So to sum it up: work on modeling instead of compositing. I know it's hard but seriously I don't think a lot of people will enjoy seeing cylinders move about forever.

Mariofan9 responds:

For starters, I'M A BEGINNER. BASIC SHAPES IS ALL I LEARNED UP 'TIL NOW.
Gee, don't we ever read descriptions these days?